23 E Magnolia Ave
Eustis, Florida 32726
By Mike Miller Updated August 31, 2023
The Great Pizza Company is located on Magnolia Avenue in historic downtown Eustis, Florida.
The Bay Theater and Ferran Park are a block away, and the popular gift shop, Peddler's Wagon, is next door.
Sandy Johnson and her late partner, Ron Butler, opened the restaurant in 2008.
They had previously owned and operated China Lane in Eustis for 34 years, and wanted to try something different.
They researched the area pizza places and could not find what they really liked: thin crust New York style pizza.
So they created their restaurant around that particular delicacy.
New York style pizza is typically made with a large hand tossed thin crust. The crust is thick and crisp only around the edge.
Traditional toppings are like any other pizza, placed over light Mozarella cheese and tomato sauce.
Sandy believes one of the big secrets of her thin crust pizza is the dough made with New York City water that she has routinely shipped to her restaurant.
Caution: many New Yorkers don't like her pizza because it is so crisp it can't be folded in true New York Pizza fashion.
Pizza is in the name of the restaurant, but there are many other items offered as well.
Appetizers include hot chicken wings, cheese sticks, fried green beans, onion rings, pork egg rolls, fried green tomatoes, garlic bread sticks, and French fries.
They have several salads starting with their house tossed salad, Caesar Salad, Chef Salad, and Greek Salad.
New York style subs are also featured including ham and cheese, salami and cheese, turkey and cheese, cheese steak, Italian combo, meatball, steak, and even a pizza sub.
There is also a wide variety of Paninis and spaghetti.
Desserts feature fried cheesecake, lemon Mascarpone torte, and a double dark chocolate brownie a la mode. Several flavors of ice cream are also served.
Beer and wine is available and in addition to booths for couples and families, there is a small bar with seating also. You can also sit outside in front of the restaurant at one of several tables.
The Great Pizza Company's operating hours are:
Mon, Wed, Thu, Fri, Sat 11am to 3pm, 4pm to 9pm
Sunday: 1pm to 8pm